Method

When the engine refuses: what makes an idea too thin to test

A sheet of off-white paper with several neat rectangular holes cut out of it, a steel ruler beside it

Why Startup Intelligence refuses ideas with too little detail, the minimum it needs, how to add it, and why a refusal beats a confident guess.

The temptation to fill the gaps

Imagine typing a single line into an idea tool: "an app that helps restaurants reduce waste". A tool that is eager to please can turn that into a market size, a revenue forecast and a list of competitors. The output looks thorough. But almost every number in it was supplied by the tool, not by you, and nothing on the page tells you which parts are yours and which were invented.

Startup Intelligence takes the opposite position. If an idea does not contain enough to test, it refuses, and tells you exactly what is missing.

What the engine needs

Every run starts by turning the idea into nine claim links: the customer; their job and pain; what they do today; the mechanism that makes your product better; the value created; the value captured; the path to the customer; the cost to serve; and what persists over time.

Two rules decide whether the run continues.

  1. At least four of the nine links must be stated in what you wrote.
  2. Two links are always required: who the customer is, and the mechanism. Without a customer there is nobody to be wrong about. Without a mechanism there is no reason for anything to change. Every other gap can become a finding; these two cannot.

You can try the rule on our home page by ticking the links an idea states. Nothing you tick is stored or sent.

What a refusal looks like

A refusal is a designed result, not an error. It states which links could not be filled and which were filled only by implication. For each empty link it offers a sentence pattern to complete, such as who exactly would use the product and what they do instead today, or why they would switch and what the current way costs them. It stops before the expensive stages run, and the screen says the run has not been counted against you.

How to add the missing detail

The missing detail is often only a few sentences. Some patterns that help:

  • The customer: name a group narrow enough to count. "Owners of single-location restaurants in Pune with more than forty covers" is testable; "restaurants" is not.
  • The mechanism: say why your product causes a better outcome. "It forecasts tomorrow's covers from bookings so the kitchen preps less" is a mechanism; "AI-powered waste reduction" is a label.
  • What they do today: include the unglamorous answers: a notebook, the chef's memory, nothing at all.
  • The price and the path: what you would charge, and how you would reach the next hundred customers.

These examples are made up to show the form, not facts about any market.

Why a refusal is better than a guess

If a tool filled in the missing links itself, its report would give you confidence about a plan you have not written yet. A refusal gives you something more useful: a precise list of the parts of your plan that are still blank. Writing those sentences can change the idea before any analysis begins.

Limits

The check looks at whether a link is stated, not whether it is true. A clearly written but wrong claim passes this stage and is tested by the later ones, where its assumptions are graded and simulated.

Takeaway

Before you ask any tool to judge an idea, make sure the idea says who it is for and why it would work. If you are not sure, the nine links are a good checklist. For what happens after a run is accepted, read what happens during a run, or see the honest refusal feature.

Reports support planning. They are not investment advice and not a guarantee of results.

Key takeaways

  • A run needs at least four of nine links, always including the customer and the mechanism.
  • A refusal names the empty links and the sentence that would fill each one.
  • A refusal is a result: it shows what the plan has not stated yet.

Questions

How much detail does an idea need?

At least four of the nine claim links stated in plain words, and always the customer and the mechanism. A few clear sentences per link is enough.

Is a refused run charged or counted?

Nothing is charged for now, and the refusal screen says the run has not been counted against you.

Startup Intelligence: what it does

Related articles

See Startup Intelligence for yourself

Request access