Features

Evidence grades: no number without a rung

A report about a future nobody has seen is only as honest as its numbers. Each one says where it came from and how much to trust it.

The problem

Idea reports often contain confident numbers: a market size, a conversion rate, a price customers will pay. Few of them say where those numbers came from. A figure someone measured and a figure someone guessed look the same on the page, so a reader cannot tell which parts of the conclusion are solid and which are hope.

How it works

In a Startup Intelligence report, a number cannot appear without a rung. The product's own code refuses to store a figure that has no rung and no note on its source. The ladder has seven rungs, grouped into three tiers:

RungNameTierWhat it means
P1MeasurementmeasuredSomeone measured it directly
P2AnalogmodelledA comparable venture's figure, with the difference stated
P3Reference classmodelledA base rate from a group of similar cases
P4Structural derivationmodelledWorked out from other figures by arithmetic
P5Constraint boundmodelledA limit the figure cannot cross
P6ElicitationassertedAn estimate someone gave when asked
P7Founder beliefassertedYour own estimate, or a figure nobody has sourced yet

The rung is printed beside the number, not in a footnote. A weakly evidenced figure is also given a wider range: the code keeps a belief from being stated more precisely than a sourced figure for the same thing. Where no figure can be given at all, the report marks the gap for you to fill in instead of inventing a value.

The report also grades its own evidence as a whole, and says plainly that this grade is about the inputs, not about your idea. A good idea can carry a weak evidence grade simply because nobody has sourced its numbers yet.

Who uses it

Anyone who has to decide how far to trust a report: the founder deciding what to test, an incubator comparing ideas, a consultant preparing a first look for a client.

Limits

Today no outside source is consulted during a run, so the base figures come from the AI model's own knowledge and sit on the lowest rungs. The ladder makes that visible rather than hiding it. Linking each assumption to published data you can open and check is planned, and until it exists the honest reading of most figures is "asserted".

Questions

Does the report give one overall score?

No. It gives no single score. Each figure carries its own rung, and the report as a whole states how much of its evidence is measured, modelled or asserted.

Where do the figures come from today?

From the AI model's own knowledge. No outside source is consulted during a run yet, so the report files those figures on the lowest rungs and says so. Linking each assumption to published data is planned.

See it on a walkthrough

Request access